A person’s career should not come down to which restroom they choose to use. Yet, for former University of Tennessee at Martin professor Johnnie LaDue, that decision ultimately cost her a four-year career at the university.

LaDue, a transgender woman who worked as an assistant professor and information media librarian, was terminated on Oct. 13 after refusing university directives to stop using the staff-only women’s restroom in the library. What followed was a series of disciplinary actions that ended with an armed campus police officer delivering her termination paperwork at her home.
The University of Tennessee at Martin declined to provide an official statement regarding LaDue’s termination, citing it as a “personnel matter” — leaving only her account to explain how the dispute unfolded.
LaDue had previously used a single-occupancy restroom in the library’s staff break room. However, she described the arrangement as uncomfortable because the restroom was located in an area where employees gathered to eat and take breaks.
“Like, imagine having a bathroom in your dining room where people are taking their break or eating or whatever,” LaDue said. “It’s awkward and a little bit demoralizing.”
Her experience highlights how a seemingly simple workplace directive can have a much deeper personal impact; having to use an alternative restroom while passing the women’s restroom near her office took an emotional toll on her.
The university’s warning cited the Riley Gaines Women’s Safety and Protection Act, which defines sex strictly as biological sex (male or female) determined at birth — and requires public restrooms, such at a public university, be designated and restricted by biological sex. LaDue continued using the women’s restroom despite being instructed otherwise. After a verbal warning, a written warning and a period of administrative leave, her employment was terminated.
Read LaDue’s Final Termination Letter here.
Evani Parker, a social work major at UT Martin, said she has mixed feelings about how the university handled the situation.
“I can understand that the university has policies it has to follow, but I also think there should be some consideration for the individual involved,” Parker said.
Following university directives is a responsibility employees are generally expected to uphold. However, that does not mean every directive should go unquestioned, particularly when it affects someone’s dignity and sense of belonging in the workplace.
Parker said she believes situations involving personal identity should be approached with compassion and understanding.
“As a social work major, I think it’s important to approach situations like this with compassion and understanding rather than immediately making someone feel unwelcome,” Parker said.
LaDue said she had no previous disciplinary issues and had passed her mid-tenure review. She also made an effort to participate in campus life, attending events and supporting students beyond her responsibilities in the library. In 2025, she received the L.A. McKee Ally and Advocate Award for faculty and staff.
Those details make her departure even more difficult to overlook. A university employee’s contributions should matter, and a person’s entire professional record should not be reduced to one disagreement with university leadership.
LaDue made her position clear when explaining why she refused to follow the directive.
“I decided to stay principled,” LaDue said. “I’m a woman. I’m going to use the women’s room, and if you’re going to fire me for that, that’s on you. But I’m not going to change who I am or diminish who I am.”
The situation also extends beyond LaDue. She described herself as the only openly transgender professor at UT Martin during her employment and expressed concern for the transgender and gender-nonconforming students who remain on campus.
“I feel way worse for the trans students on campus,” LaDue said. “I can’t imagine exactly how that feels, but it can’t feel great.”
Parker also expressed concern about what the situation could mean for students and their sense of belonging on campus.
“At the end of the day, I think people deserve to feel safe and respected, regardless of their identity,” Parker said.
LaDue’s statement that she would rather be unemployed than unprincipled speaks to the personal cost of standing by her convictions.
“I decided a long time ago when I started teaching, I would rather be unemployed than unprincipled,” she said. “That doesn’t mean I wanted to be unemployed. Not at all.”
Her termination should prompt serious reflection about how universities handle disagreements involving employees, personal identity and institutional policies.
No employee should have to feel that maintaining their sense of self means sacrificing their livelihood. Whatever the disagreement, there should be room for dignity, understanding and meaningful consideration before a career comes to an end.



