The Pacer

Independent voice of the University of Tennessee at Martin

Arts & Entertainment Movies Reviews

The Four Horsemen of Illusionists return in ‘Now You See Me: Now You Don’t’

Featured Image: (Pacer Graphic / Darby Self)

Illusion not only challenges the realms of magic but also the precision of time.

Some notable illusionists whose craft leaves their audience in wonder are: Harry Houdini, David Blaine and Criss Angel.

However, did they hypnotize an audience member at their show to rob a bank in Paris, France and leave the Incredible Hulk, Mark Ruffalo—playing as an federal agent (Dylan Rhodes)—to hunt them down and figure out how they created this grand scheme?

Absolutely not, as this is the plot to one of the most exhilarating films of all time: Now You See Me, directed by Louis Leterrier and released on May 31, 2013.

The original film featured a team of four talented illusionists: J. Daniel Atlas (Jesse Eisenberg), Merritt McKinney (Woody Harrelson), Jack Wilder (Dave Franco) and Henley Reeves (Isla Fisher), who call themselves the “Four Horsemen.”

(L-R) Isla Fisher, Jesse Eisenberg, Woody Harrelson, and Dave Franco star in ‘Now You See Me’ | (Photo Credit / Barry Wetcher)

They host elaborate magic shows—leaving the audience mesmerized by their tricks—but these are not just ordinary cat-and-mouse illusions. The Four Horsemen dismantle the greedy, corrupt elites and redirect that money to the hardworking people in the audience. A federal agent named Dylan Rhodes (Mark Ruffalo) and his detective partner, Alma Dray (Mélanie Laurent), are tasked to track down the Four Horsemen; because, even though they give back to the vulnerable, it is still considered a crime of bank heist and robbery.

The two turn to Thaddeus Bradley (Morgan Freeman), a famous illusionist turned debunker, for help. Little did Thaddeus know, all along, Dylan was an illusionist himself and helped the Four Horsemen conquer their plan.

Now that I have taken the liberty of giving a backstory of the film series; with the exception of the second film, due to it failing to resonate with the audience and the absence of Isla Fisher’s character, let us dive into the latest installment: Now You See Me: Now You Don’t.

 

CAUTION: SPOILERS AHEAD

 

This film marks the third installment in the film series and was released on Nov. 14, 2025.

It introduced a rising new generation of illusionists: Bosco, (Dominic Sessa), Charlie (Justice Smith) and June (Ariana Greenblatt) who are hungry to make a name for themselves in the world of magic.

Their skills are showcased in a deep-fake AI (Artificial Intelligence) generated 10th anniversary celebration for the original Four Horsemen and turn the performance into a spectacle as they outed a crypto dealer and redistributed his wealth to the audience. What the teens did not know was that J. Daniel Atlas, or ‘Danny,’ one of the original Four Horsemen, watched the creative trick in the crowd and recruits them—on behalf of the Eye (secret society of the world’s most skilled magicians that aim to bring justice to the underprivileged and take down the corrupt), to steal “the Heart.” It is depicted as the world’s largest diamond owned by powerful mogul, Veronika Vanderburg (Rosamund Pike).

I admired how the film added a modern touch by incorporating AI, which is on the way to becoming the new normal in today’s society. With features such as deep-fake that can digitally alters a person’s face, body or voice; anyone can present themselves as someone else and keep plenty of tricks up their sleeve—to take down malicious elites, of course, and not necessarily spread false information (I hope.)

The trio and Danny realized they might of underestimated Veronika and her capabilities, so the rest of the Four Horsemen: Merritt, Jack and their iconic flyer, Henley reunite after 10 years to lend a helping hand.

(L-R): Dave Franco (Jack), Jesse Eisenberg (Danny), Woody Harrelson (Merritt), Isla Fisher (Henley), Justice Smith (Charlie), Ariana Greenblatt (June), and Dominic Sessa (Bosco) star in ‘Now You See Me: Now You Don’t.’ | (Photo Credit / IGN)

I despise the second film and refused to watch it when Henley did not return and was replaced with the character, Lula May, played by Lizzy Caplan. You may know Caplan as the goth, witty and artistic, Janis Ian from the cut-classic, Mean Girls; however, her performance in Now You See Me 2 did not quite live up to viewer’s exceptions—including my own.

Seeing Henley grace the screen once again as the original female “Horsemen,” truly warmed my heart.

As the group works together through high-stakes obstacles to unveil the secrets linked to the Vanderburg’s empire that Veronika inherited, another foe enters the fray. Thaddeus helps hide them from the police and Veronika at a puzzling estate in France (he sadly dies after being shot in a police raid.) Each room has its own illusion elements: a hall of mirrors, an upside-down chamber where the characters are able to walk on the ceiling and a optical-illusion room where people appear to look huge or small, depending on where they stand. The final room includes a bright glow of white-and-silver space that warps viewer’s perception as the characters appear in multiple angles.

Overall, the cinematography and visuals in this film was next-level, featuring fast-paced and polished aspects that mimic the feeling of watching a live magic trick unfold.

In the end, it was revealed that Charlie was the mastermind behind the entire heist to take down Veronika and brought the Four Horsemen together—including the addition of Lula May. Charlie is actually the younger half-brother of Veronika who she believed died fifteen years earlier. This was a jaw-dropping plot twist of the movie. In grand fashion, he exposes Veronika at a live-magic show using her own recorded confession.

Mark Ruffalo also makes his return as Dylan Rhodes but as a hologram message to the Four Horsemen, which leaves the film off on a cliffhanger.

During a free showing of the film at the Cine Theater on Nov. 17, 2025 in Martin, Tenn. which was hosted by UT Martin’s Flight Crew; students shared their thoughts and opinions on the movie.

“This movie was different from the others because it wasn’t one person who controls the entire trick that they were planning which made it different,” said Samuel Harris, a freshman nursing major.

Brandon Bishop, a freshman graphic design major liked how the film makers “modernize the movie by using the aspects of technology and AI within the movie.” However, compared to the other films, he felt that the latest installment was a bit worse.

Chanel Wilkins, a freshman Mass Media Strategic Communications major, has never watched the previous films but said, “Honestly, the movie was really good and by far one of my favorites. It had me on the edge of my seat practically the whole time. Although, I haven’t seen the other films, people recommended that I watch it especially after seeing the newest one. The little subtle hints at F1 also had me excited since that’s something I’ve always been interested in.”

The film, Now You See Me: Now You Don’t topped the global box-office charts with $75.5 million in its opening week—becoming one of the must-see movies of the year. I highly recommend watching this if you enjoy the art of optical illusion and a great heist.

And remember, “No matter what cards life deals you, you have to learn to make your own magic,” said by Charlie Vanderburg in the final scenes of Now You See Me: Now You Don’t.

Grade: 9.5/10